Cyprus Problem Forum Index
JusticeForCyprus.comCyprus LinksRegisterSearchFAQMemberlistUsergroupsLog in
Reply to topic                 Page 1 of 2
Goto page 1, 2  Next
Pros and Cons of The Annan Plan: Why did it Fail?
Should Have the Annan Plan Been Voted In?

Yes 42% 42% ( 3 )
No 42% 42% ( 3 )
Unsure 14% 14% ( 1 )

Total Votes : 7
Author Message
Reply with quote
Post Pros and Cons of The Annan Plan: Why did it Fail? 
Hi all

To look forward we must look at the Annan plan and why it didnt work and wasnt accepted. All discussion welcome. Looking at the pros and cons may be a good way to start

Rousias Cool

View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
Reply with quote
Post  
The Annan plan failed miserably, because and this is my opinion, it did not guarantee the sovereignity of Cyprus, as a whole country, but rather divided it into portions...

For example it did not get rid of the guarantors, Turkey , Greece and England...This is unheard off of a country that is a full member of the EU...If anything it cemented their powers.

Also I found it absurd that Cypriots were prohibited in settling anywhere they wished in their own country, while any European could...Too many derogations for my liking.

I didn't like the fact that a judicial system was based on foreugn judges...I did not also like the style of government that it proposed...

Further more it cemented UK's rights on the island while actually giving them more territory...They would have gained more ground in the form of a slice of the continental shelf...I also found this unacceptable..

I also like t mention that a lot depended on Turkey joining the EU...But it did not address what about if Turkey doesn't get in the EU...What happens then?...What about if Turkey took a different path to the EU, and they snubbed the EU?

I think end of the day the plan dead, from the moment it was signed...And I am really surpriced to this very day that the UN, Turkey, Greece and the UK didn't see this coming...What a waste of an oppurtunity...



Last edited by Michael on Thu Jun 01, 2006 10:57 pm; edited 1 time in total
View user's profile Send private message
Reply with quote
Post  
ok who voted yes and why?

View user's profile Send private message
Reply with quote
Post  
not me Very Happy Very Happy Very Happy Very Happy Very Happy Very Happy


_________________
Turkish Troops Out of Cyprus
View user's profile Send private message
Reply with quote
Post  
Wasnt me, but who ever it was can you tell us why? Cool

View user's profile Send private message
Reply with quote
Post  
The EU, admittedly, has undertaken a new initiative, that will inexorably lead to the political acknowledgement of the north. Several measure are currently being discussed in Brussels including the opening of the ports and airport in the north, the offer of direct financial assistance and the upgrading of the EU office. Add to this the EU decisions about direct trade, the free movement of EU citizens across the Green Line (even if they have arrived through an illegal port of entry) and plans to have Turkish Cypriots represented at EU fora, and there is little doubt that the ultimate objective is political recognition. The United States government is moving along the same lines, according to the Greek lobby.

This is not the kind of opportunity for a “European solution” that Papadopoulos and his backers have in mind. In fact, the government is opposed to all the proposed measures being discussed in Brussels, but whether it will be able to block them, given its current isolation, is questionable. The truth is that the EU and the US have embarked on a course that will not only end the international isolation of the north but will also ensure political recognition and, ultimately, partition.

Papadopoulos has said that the Greek Cypriots are being punished for rejecting a settlement, and he may be right, but complaining will get us nowhere. It is clear what the EU and the US are doing. They are showing the Greek Cypriots what the consequences (of which we had been repeatedly warned) of the “resounding no” will be. The Turkish Cypriot administration will be politically recognised and will have direct contacts with other states, while the economy in the north will be helped to develop with large amounts of aid. And once their isolation ends and they start enjoying the benefits of economic growth, why would the Turkish Cypriots want re-unification? Partition would be the solution.

As Kofi Annan and the US have said, there will be no other initiatives for a solution. In other words, the only option we have of preventing partition is holding a second referendum on the Annan plan, on our own initiative, and voting ‘yes’, before December, when Turkey is likely to be given a date for the start of EU accession negotiations. This appears to be the only way of preventing the political recognition of the north that will result in partition. This is the loud and clear message – some could describe it as a clear threat – from the international community, which has proved it is not bluffing.

Editorial - Just what kind of a solution are we looking for?
(archive article - Sunday, May 16, 2004)

And you still think it can get better?


Very Happy Very Happy Very Happy Very Happy

View user's profile Send private message
Reply with quote
Post  
Quote:
(archive article - Sunday, May 16, 2004)


Hey Paul, that article is indeed a downer, but a lot have happened since then...wouldn't you agree? Wink

View user's profile Send private message
Reply with quote
Post  
Quote:
Papadopoulos has said that the Greek Cypriots are being punished for rejecting a settlement, and he may be right, but complaining will get us nowhere. It is clear what the EU and the US are doing. They are showing the Greek Cypriots what the consequences (of which we had been repeatedly warned) of the “resounding no” will be. The Turkish Cypriot administration will be politically recognised and will have direct contacts with other states, while the economy in the north will be helped to develop with large amounts of aid. And once their isolation ends and they start enjoying the benefits of economic growth, why would the Turkish Cypriots want re-unification? Partition would be the solution.


In todays democracy, why should GC's be punished for voting NO to the plan?

View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
Reply with quote
Post  
rousias wrote:
Quote:
Papadopoulos has said that the Greek Cypriots are being punished for rejecting a settlement, and he may be right, but complaining will get us nowhere. It is clear what the EU and the US are doing. They are showing the Greek Cypriots what the consequences (of which we had been repeatedly warned) of the “resounding no” will be. The Turkish Cypriot administration will be politically recognised and will have direct contacts with other states, while the economy in the north will be helped to develop with large amounts of aid. And once their isolation ends and they start enjoying the benefits of economic growth, why would the Turkish Cypriots want re-unification? Partition would be the solution.


In todays democracy, why should GC's be punished for voting NO to the plan?


If western democracy was so strong would the invasion of Irak happen as i am guessing that the people would have voted no to any war.

That said i feel the international community have no problem with the way you voted but the way the ROC and in particular Tpap went about to get that infamous 'oxi' vote. Wink

View user's profile Send private message
Reply with quote
Post  
Quote:
If western democracy was so strong would the invasion of Irak happen as i am guessing that the people would have voted no to any war.


The Actions of the US here really showed thier true colours in Iraq with their decieptfull invasion purposes and ill treatment and torture of civilians and POW's . . Was there a vote before the US invaded?

View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website
Display posts from previous:
Reply to topic Page 1 of 2
Goto page 1, 2  Next
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum
You can attach files in this forum
You can download files in this forum
  


Thanks to phpbb, phpBBStyles.com, Webstudio